Fshud vs pro atc sr

Fshud vs pro atc sr. Only supports IFR as far as i know. Microsoft Flight Simulator (MSFS 2020) Prepar3D 5. Jun 14, 2022 · FSHud launched on Prepar3D last month and the developers said that they were working on a version for Microsoft Flight Simulator. I am, as I write performing a flight (SAWH-SAZS), using FSHUD 1. Other ATC replacements were the same. This works by controlling the ATC, and aircraft in the vicinity and working with the player who provides input to the system. Being able to use my voice is important as well so here is my experience. Customers who have purchased the old version of 'PRO-ATC/X' will get PRO-ATC/SR for 44. April 4, 2024. FENIX Airbus A320. Create flight plans, have them created Jul 14, 2022 · I was thinking of getting an ATC addon. I just hate using ProATC/SR and having me and another AI plane taxi right into each other…. Leonardo MaddogX. I read what FSHud has in its advertising and decided to spend 34 euros, convinced above all by the Nov 2, 2022 · Whereas FSHud they update all the time but all the updates they release are rather small things that don’t even need to be addressed at that time…. Aug 12, 2022 · PRO ATC SR - FBW A32NX - kompletter Funk EDDV nach EDDB ★ MSFS 2020 DeutschMicrosoft Flight Simulator 2020 / MS Flight Simulator 2020 / Flight Simulator 2020 Oct 16, 2022 · In questo video andremo a vedere un software molto utile per la gestione dell'ATC all'interno di MSFS, pienamente compatibile con il nuovo traffico FSLTL. Oct 31, 2022 · FS Hud has more development ongoing and is promising, especially as it can control traffic better, but it’s not there to be an sufficient alternative. But still significantly lacking, as it will sometimes vector you way out of the way and just leave you hanging. 95 GB RAM usable)Current resolution: 1920 x 1080, 60HzOperating system: In this MSFS live stream, we take a detailed look at FSHud ATC for Microsoft Flight Simulator. Sep 1, 2023 · I just gave up on Pilot 2 Atc, it’s frustration after frustration and I am very patient. This doesn't work, when running PRO-ATC/X on a client and the sim on a server. - Harry. Please send us a short email Feb 19, 2023 · I was weak and actually bought both FSHud and BATC (and Pilot2ATC… haha). It's odd how most ATC-addons don't do what you expect them to do: CONTROL the traffic. You can also import your simbrief flightplan. During my long flight simulator time i bouth Pilot2atc, FSHud, PF3 and Pro-Atc SR. found here; The software is a complete in sim ATC replacement and is currently available for other platforms but looks like it may be coming to MSFS. Is it perfect, no, but compared to current options, it does the job for me. Sep 3, 2023 · Pilot2atc with Amazon Polly voices (free) and FSLTL… It’s ugly, it’s hard to setup, has a clunky user interface but it’s by far the best solution. 3 Beta and it is the best offline Atc and AI experience I had in twenty years of Flightsim. Export the simbrief plan via download and then import into ProATC SR. FSHud is out as the feeling I get from comments is that its only marginally better than default ATC plus no VFR. This is a long-awaite Aug 9, 2022 · PRO-ATC/SR is available for 49. Financially, yes, it is indeed a new version Sep 1, 2023 · Hello, I use to be a ProATC person and now I use FSHUD. Flight Simulator X-SE. I have only used FSHUD a few time (Only 80hours of flight time since MS2020 came out) but I always use it for IFR Jul 20, 2022 · On 7/19/2022 at 7:33 PM, Deltaair1212 said: I have been using PATCX for my ATC needs. Aug 14, 2022 · Pointsoft has released PRO-ATC/SR for Microsoft Flight Simulator and Prepar3D. Their forum is a wasteland, where the mod spends most of his time, it seems, yelling at folks to "post their real names" under their posts, as if posting your "real name" (why anyone would do this on a random internet forum is beyond me) is like rubbing Aladin's Aug 28, 2023 · Hi there I posted this in “What ATC” discussion post and put it here about my experience and wishes about FSHUD . Jun 16, 2022 · FSHud - Air Traffic Control is a new add-on for MSFS which aims to bring realistic ATC to Microsoft Flight Simulator. Unterstützte Flugzeuge. Thereafter for 59. FSHud was released over a year ago originally for Prepar3D, but then soon made the transition over to MSFS to provide improvements to the ATC system found in the simulator. But I also know there is no way around it and it sucks. steam, atc, live-traffic, pilot2atc Jan 4, 2024 · ProATC/SR (Speech Recognition) ProATC/SR is an ATC add-on for IFR flying in Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 (MSFS), Prepar3D, and FSX. Also we will be taking a look at the beautiful rendetion of Ibiza In FSHud - Air Traffic Control makes it possible to control every aircraft in your simulator via ATC - available now in the Shop for MSFS and P3D v4-6! Oct 31, 2022 · ProAtc/SR: PROS: ATC assigns runway, SID, STAR. Thanks, but I was hoping this could be a thread talking about all three in one place. Vectors out of departure are good, and vectors to final are better than FSHud. kjacrobat September 13, 2022, 7:52pm 2. This product is available in the Flight1 Agent. If you have FSLTL, you will launch it and FSHud. Sep 4, 2023 · Since many, here and other sources told me that FSHUD integrates pretty good with FSLTL Trafic Injection, and that ATC PRO/SR is somewhat abandonned by the devs, I decided to get FSHUD. 95 GB RAM usable)Current resolution: 1920 x 1080, 60HzOperating system: The team at FSHud were so kind to give me a copy for you to have a look at so here's my first lo Hi all, I'm a PMDG tech team member and real life 737 pilot. 5. xbox , bug-logged , living-world , traffic , atc , su12-beta. 4 Alpha 1 in P3D4. No release date but it looks and sounds incredible. Either: Direct SB import. 1 Like. PRO_ATC/SR is now in Internal testing. it has all the usual issues that AI ATC has - it doesn't quite understand SIDs/STARs and will fumble descents or guiding you in to approach more often than not. Jul 14, 2022 · In my opinion, while better than default ATC, FSHud has some issues around how it injects traffic. ATC just randomly start ignoring me and then you start troubleshooting and troubleshooting and nothing seem to be working. For P3D v4 and v5 We are initially releasing FSHud for Prepar3D v4 or v5. Pretty fun to follow planes to the active runway and listen to their ATC communication as they roll out ahead of you. Customers who have purchased the old version of 'PRO-ATC/X' between May and August of this year 2022, before release of PRO-ATC/SR will get PRO-ATC/SR for 19. Nov 2, 2022 · Whereas FSHud they update all the time but all the updates they release are rather small things that don’t even need to be addressed at that time…. 27. If your idea of fun is crashing your plane as quickly as possible, this is not the program for you. 5 GHz, Z690) - 32 GB RAM (DDR5 6400, CAS 34), RTX 3090 - Windows 11 Pro (1TB M. It can use bgl traffic files so programs like AIG AIM can be used, but after doing 10 flights with FSHud, I found that 100% of the time on approach, arrival, and at the destination gate there was hardly ever any traffic despite having traffic set Dec 18, 2023 · General question about Pro ATC. Pilot2ATC is great, and has options for other realistic voices (now includes direct flight plan import from Simbrief). doesn’t make the product really compelling. There are definitely some things I miss about FSHud: Traffic injection with FSHud also controlling all the injected traffic. No easy way to tell how to actually taxi or where to taxi to. Customers who have purchased the old version of 'PRO-ATC/X Aug 9, 2022 · That's a neat feature. Honnestly, I’m pretty impressed by it. FSCaptain 1. There are a couple ATC threads (pros/cons) going on over on Avsim. 95 € until September, 15, 2022. Com Dec 1, 2023 · Updated: 02-Dec-2023 @ 10:35z. FShud uses an API key to connect with FS Traffic, just disable FS Traffic module in Traffic Control Centre and you're good to go. AIG AI Manager and Traffic Controller for MSFS. It only removes it when needed. AivlaSoft SimpleCam, AS P3D4, ISG Gauges, Pro-ATC/X, SimElite TZ Fixer. And can only do one thing. Unless it changed in last version. Dec 14, 2023 · Driven by the decline in Realtraffic data coverage for PSXT, I wanted to enjoy a new ATC for a bit. FSHud seems to be great too, but it doesn´t offer speech recognition. April 5, 2024. good or bad. Although, if I can enjoy some airliner trafic in high density area like Dublin, EGLL, but also quieter places I can do with Ryanair or Easyjet. I have also used PRO-ATC/SR, but it seems more like a port over from P3D, just with added speech recognition that feels canned. ATC repeats the same flight level instructions for the same AI aircraft multuple. Top priority was focused on to not restrict the simulation in any way. Thanks and good to know about FSHud. Jun 20, 2022 · Watch a full flight with realistic ATC using FSHud, a new add-on for MSFS 2020. Yea, I'm just lurking here right now to see what some of the new users of this new ATC addon have to say about it. Don’t have time for this lol… In this live stream we will be conducting a review of Pro ATC SR voice command for MSFS. Dec 18, 2023 · Tabularasa1292 November 10, 2022, 11:34am 26. It is worth noting I fly with FSLTL traffic, that could be causing the problems. I have done a review of the good, and the Nov 10, 2022 · Once I figured out workarounds for all of the little bugs in ProAtc/SR I rarely have problems and have given up going to the draconian forums or expecting an update anytime soon. Keeping AI out of your way isn't 'controlling' AI. Pro-ATC/SR is the most complete Air Traffic Control (ATC) add-on for Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 (MSFS), Prepar3D and FSX-SE. However it suffers from awful performance, long loading times and random crashes. Mar 13, 2024 · Looking at FSHud, they (and probably VoxATC as well) are now working on it for at least a year and while it basically works it showed that the devil is in the details. the other huge problem is that it is utterly unforgiving with phraseology and really hard to understand when it speaks to Jun 11, 2022 · With FSHud, simmers have the ability to listen to two different channels, each with its own independent volumes. And yes I own all the Atc addons! They totally reworked the voices, the AI is now great in combination with Fsltl liveries. It is not really a new version. 3103 beta version, FSLTL and the unavoidable A320 Fenix, and so far, it's a charm. Apr 8, 2023 · Ok, everybody should get ready for the new version of Fshud. SkyVagrant4490 October 30, 2022, 9:36am 3. Nov 17, 2022 · The best bet is to just not use the product honestly. It interacts with the AI(even the injected AI), the voice set has improved over the years, you can declare emergencies, as well as perform holds. This is a NEW version and not an update and works also with MSFS2020. Jan 22, 2024 · Bottom line is if you come across this thread as part of your atc research DO NOT buy Pro-atc/SR! I personally switched to FSHud recently and have been very happy with that despite lack of some features (e. Sep 2, 2023 · PF3 has been my ATC choice. I am now participating in the 1. P2ATC: most reliable in terms of loading flightplans and overall functionality, tho a bit complicated to set the flightplan up. Never leaves you hanging at an altitude. Though I’m hoping to have experienced flight simmer with one or many of the above platform, what are the pros & cons for each. You may want to look that one up. The new version has been released, which now supports MSFS to add a new ATC system for simmers. Has an arrow to direct you for Aug 9, 2022 · Right now, I'm still experimenting with FSHud and the developers have been on top of things. Sep 3, 2023 · My goal would be to Inject trafic using FSLTL trafic injector (Using FSLTL Trafic Models), and use an offline ATC such as P2A, FSHud or ATC Pro/SR. If you're reporting a bug (and you should!) I'll likely ask you to email us your latest \FSCaptain\Data\Logs\ files. Besides, FSHud helps the pilot with routine tasks, such as automatic position reporting and switching comm channels. Partially 1 or 2 frames - if at all. They are only closing, when clicking on 'Close Window' or if a function is executed. Pro Atc SR, didn't like it because of some bugs. I bought it a long time ago, but having used it for a month or two I got tired of the constant vectoring issues (telling me turn left 10, turn right 10, turn left 10…even wiith the corridor set as wide as i could make it). The one to look forward to is Beyond ATC. So this is an opinion based question obviously. I miss the AI voice recognition for a better interaction with May 2, 2024 · FSHud vs ATC PRO/SR vs Pilot2Atc - Best current Offline ATC Solution? Tools & Utilities. Aug 9, 2022 · The achilles heel of Pro ATC SR is the non-existing support from the developer. Aug 10, 2022 · PRO-ATC/SR is available right now for Microsoft Flight Simulator, with varying prices depending on your current standing with the program. I have seen a few complaints about voices on the forum. We believe that Pro-ATC/SR will take Air Traffic Control to the next level. Mar 13, 2024 · Beyond ATC looks quite promising, but who knows how good / buggy it will be when released. I sometimes couldn’t get p2atc to understand me (I’m a native english speaker and did try to train it). These range from weather reports, clearances and taxi instructions all the way to vectors, landing clearances and traffic calls. Available for MSFS and Prepar3D v4 and v5, and v6! Air Traffic Control - Reimagined! Dont know about FS HUD, but for example FSLTL (free) works perfectly with FS traffic as a new update of FSLTL allows to uses FS Traffic models, hence better performance. I miss the AI voice recognition for a better interaction with Jul 10, 2022 · FS2020 SDK doesn’t allow for reading the weather from the sim, so you just need to use Live Weather, and then FSHud uses their own weather servers to retrieve live weather data. Jul 29, 2022 · In order to use FSHud ATC addon with MS Flight Simulator 2020, you need to modify a few user settings to avoid conflict with the built-in AI Air Traffic cont For other AI-ATC's you currently have the option of Pilot2ATC, Pro-ATC/SR and FSHUD. In my opinion it is not user friendly (just my uneducated opinion) Nov 9, 2022 · Whereas FSHud they update all the time but all the updates they release are rather small things that don’t even need to be addressed at that time…. PMDG 736-NGXU. Email us by following the details here. i9-13900K (HT off, 5. FSHud clearly is a work in progress in this regard but at least it is trying. imho, this is still the best atc program (and I’ve spent hours trying demos of the others). CONS: Constant vectoring which takes you off course for ILS. Makes it so boring, I’d rather have robotic May 7, 2022 · There are still some issues like reduced ai traffic at larger airports and lacking "save flight situation". I bet there's 95% of the old code of PRO ATC X untouched. FunnierFlea3491 November 10, 2022, 12:20pm 27. Again, p2atc has great dev support. Jun 14, 2022 · FSHud - neues ATC/AI Traffic Tool - Schönefeld - Frankfurt ★ MSFS 2020 DeutschMicrosoft Flight Simulator 2020 / MS Flight Simulator 2020 / Flight Simulator 2 Aug 9, 2022 · It doesn't interact with AI at all. The instructions are very straight foward. I use FSLTL to manage the traffic and have Dec 29, 2022 · Export the simbrief plan via download and then import into ProATC SR. 57 version, updated last saturday 25 august works fine , even introducing GA (go around )randomly at landing the sounds improvement better with very good looking almost real radio ATC sounds . Aug 9, 2022 · It doesn't interact with AI at all. Oct 30, 2022 · FS Hud has more development ongoing and is promising, especially as it can control traffic better, but it’s not there to be an sufficient alternative. Also being able to go to airports with worse or no ground coverage and see how FSHud, in conjunction with FSLTL, injected and controlled planes. The interface used is the FS standard interface "SimConnect". FSHud is the only ATC addon that tries to do that (though not exactly perfect yet). EDIT To be more precise: The actual traffic (AI) continues to be controlled by the flight simulation but is detected and considered and even changed by PRO-ATC/SR. As for existing owners of an older version, a few discounts are available depending on the time of Jul 14, 2022 · Posted July 14, 2022 (edited) Not long to wait now, PRO-ATC/SR is now in internal Alpha testing. Apr 8, 2023 · The only external atc that provides traffic control is fshud. If only it had better support and a few updates it could be truly excellent. ATC does not recognize or respect altitude constrictions. … The last FSHUD 1. A completely new version including MSFS202 support has been announced in the internal forum - in the near future! Quote: " You have all been waiting, well just a little bit longer. PRO-ATC/SR is available for 49. It'll even re-open the menu on some In this live MSFS stream, we take a look at the recently released Pro ATC SR for Microsoft Flight Simulator. Using PRO-ATC/SR, you'll not notice significant loss of frames per second. Pilot2ATC seemed like the clear choice and based on the extra bells and whistles it offers like flight planning, moving map etc, I was thinking of buying that. . 2) - MSFS 2020 (MS Store, on May 24, 2023 · About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright Sep 1, 2023 · Work with AI trafic also ? It is not complicated at all. g. 1737. Aug 14, 2022 · Today’s video sees us testing out and demonstrating the brand new Pro ATC X / Pro ATC SR for Microsoft Flight Simulator from Pointsoft. Sep 2, 2023 · Thanks for you feedback sir, Yeah, I kinda get it, there are no perfect solution and our best hope is in Beyond ATC. Sep 13, 2022 · Especially if anyone has tried all three or use AIG. Jul 8, 2023 · First time ever that I bother sharing my humble opinion about anything related to FS. And yes, it will still retrieve METARS. But I'm pretty sure that I will completely replace ProATC-X with FSHud within the next few months. The voice Jan 18, 2023 · In pro-atc/sr when it gets lost I could usually get it back on track by requesting direct to waypoint. Flying online is nice, but you'll be on your own once there is no controller in charge for a certain frequency - our experience is, that Nov 10, 2022 · Export the simbrief plan via download and then import into ProATC SR. Yes, the UI is “old” since it was based on the old PF2000 from the FS98/2000 days. Otherwise what you also can do is manually copy the route from SIMBRIEF into ProATC SR. FSHud - Air Traffic Control. However, it works. If you want an ATC that has more features, and is voice controlled / activated (that you can also have your co-pilot handle). This also removes STARS etc. Note I only use ATC for IFR flights so can’t comment on VFR, although I’ve used these programs successfully with GA aircraft and IFR flights. x and below. Nov 10, 2022 · Export the simbrief plan via download and then import into ProATC SR. $34. But just as other ATC addons, apart from FSHud, it doesn't control traffic at all. Including care of conflicts forecasts and traffic separation. The tool is described to be in complete control of the air traffic within the simulator – both on the ground and in Sep 7, 2022 · Posted September 8, 2022. PRO-ATC/SR is an air traffic control tool that aims to enhance your sim by giving you instructions. Firstly, we have no release date but hopefully it should not be very long before entering BETA. Für MSFS. Pro ATC SR by Pointsoft is an Air Traffic Contro Oct 31, 2022 · Whereas FSHud they update all the time but all the updates they release are rather small things that don’t even need to be addressed at that time…. 3 days ago · 311. Jun 9, 2022 · Win11 Pro - 12700K stock; 32GB @5200; RTX 3070Ti. I can say that Pro-ATC at least for me provided best results as follow: - Traffic Control very accurate with right phraseology and instructions - Support Holding - Provided correct TOC instructions in order to make a perfect landing - Low CPU comsumption Aug 9, 2022 · Setting aside the obvious spelling errors just in the product description alone, the disparaging opening line: Pro-ATC/SR is meant for people who take their flying seriously. I made a flight from Copenhagen to Prague, and it managed the trafic very well, including my aircraft, got a lot of instructions, it gave me a STAR even though my FP had Nov 16, 2023 · My goal would be to Inject trafic using FSLTL trafic injector (Using FSLTL Trafic Models), and use an offline ATC such as P2A, FSHud or ATC Pro/SR. Has decent voiceovers not to robotic. Pilot2atc can auto assign sid/star/runways dependent on real weather, it can do vectoring and go arounds, give instruction for obeying height restrictions and shouting if speed restrictions are not met, or if you are ofcourse. ProAtc/SR: PROS: ATC assigns runway, SID, STAR. The tool takes into account standard May 14, 2022 · The problems with the default ATC are well known ofc. Just like using FSLTL…. Click here to read more Open in Flight1 Agent Get Agent. This is something that needs to be added to the FS2020 SDK. Learn how to install and use FSHud for a better flight experience. speech recognition). They are making improvements. FSHud - Air Traffic Control completely handles AI Traffic during all stages in a low level (including parking, taxi, takeoff/landing and airborne). Note that some features may differ in the MSFS version to do i really enjoyed pilot2atc at first but regret buying it now. ATC, Traffic & NAVAIDs. [New] PRO-ATC/X now recognizes which simulation is loaded (FSX/P3D), provided it is running on the same PC. Irvsax82 September 13, 2022, 11:31pm 3. On vatsim, if I fly to remote places, forget it, no control, no trafic, nothing at all. FSHud: PROS: Injects and controls AI traffic. Flying online is nice, but you'll be on your own once there is no controller in charge for a certain frequency - our experience is, that Aug 9, 2022 · I tested Pilot2ATC, PF3 and I own FSHud and Pro-ATC/SR. I really like it and it injects and controls the traffic movement. [New] In-Flight menus are re-worked. 95€. It does read the taxiways Okay by using a guiding arrow in the FSHud window. Never did a complete flight without problems. pro-atc/sr just works without issue. Jul 27, 2022 · If you want ATC like the Sim has, but functional, then FSHud is probably your best bet. New customers can get PRO-ATC/SR for 49. I do believe however that PRO ATC-R will launch a rather impressive update in the near future. More lenient voice rec. FSHud is one of the best for me. Its key feature is the use of speech recognition, allowing you to interact via a computer microphone. On ground comms with AI work totally fine. Yepp, exactly that seems to be the key. the price will then go up to 59. 95. It will work with AI. In particular airborne traffic separation and sequencing apparently proved to be a major task and they still haven't released a public beta version with a working airborne May 7, 2022 · Just saw this on @dTwotonemurphy latest edition of “the news”. FSHud - Air Traffic Control brings life-like Air Traffic Control to MSFS and Prepar3D v6, v5, and v4. It also offers background ATC communications and worldwide coverage. We will be conducting a full flight from Bahrain International Apr 8, 2023 · Ok, everybody should get ready for the new version of Fshud. In the other line of the channel, pilots will find different voices, with more to come in future updates. This should work. 95€ until September 15. We are planning to bring FSHud to MSFS. GPU: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 3700X 8-Core ProcessorMemory: 32 GB RAM (31. Jul 29, 2022 · Take a trip with Ziggy and find out if the new ATC addon for MS Flight Simulator 2020 is the answer to bad AI ATC. But I have used both and there are pros and cons to both so let’s start. There are a couple of videos which will help you out. On 9/7/2022 at 5:21 PM, sunny_in_the_sky said: The reason I say new is because a new version called PRO ATC SR came out, as opposed to the old PRO ATC X. It just don’t work. Yes, direct import does not work for me either. The team at FSHud were so kind to PRO-ATC/SR just runs autonomously beside the Flight Simulation (MSFS, Prepar3D or FSX-SE). Archer374 September 13, 2022, 11:45pm 4. PMDG 737-NGXU. I followed them on Facebook where they were discussing Aug 28, 2023 · Hi there I posted this in “What ATC” discussion post and put it here about my experience and wishes about FSHUD . pro-atc/sr has horrible dev support. 95 €. Nov 9, 2022 · Whereas FSHud they update all the time but all the updates they release are rather small things that don’t even need to be addressed at that time…. 8. Nov 10, 2022 · Hi, FSHud is excellent (I use it all the time as it’s much better than default ATC) but it does not have S/R. There are a lot of improvements and updates the most notable one is now PRO-ATC can Aug 7, 2022 · Pro-ATC/SR is the most complete Air Traffic Control (ATC) add-on for Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 (MSFS), Prepar3D and FSX-SE. . ch fp ve fi ln wa zk bb tq nm